“I Died for Beauty But Was Scarce” by Emily Dickinson explores the themes of beauty and truth, suggesting that these two ideals, represented by the two deceased individuals in the poem, are closely connected and may even be inseparable. The poem also reflects on the idea of death and how time eventually obscures the identities and achievements of individuals, as symbolized by the moss covering their names.

I Died for Beauty But Was Scarce By Emily Dickinson

I died for beauty,

But was scarce

Adjusted in the tomb,

When one who died for truth was lain In an adjoining room.

He questioned softly why I failed?

“For beauty,” I replied.

“And I for truth, -the two are one;

We brethren are,” he said.  

And so, as kinsmen met a night,

We talked between the rooms,

Until the moss had reached our lips,

And covered up our names.

I Died for Beauty But Was Scarce: Poem Analysis

“I Died for Beauty” is a profound and thought-provoking poem that explores themes of mortality, truth, and beauty. It consists of three quatrains, each containing four lines, and follows a simple ABCB rhyme scheme. Despite its brevity, the poem is rich in symbolism and layers of meaning.

In the first stanza, the speaker, who has died for beauty, reflects on their situation. They find themselves in a tomb but feel that they are not fully adjusted or settled in their final resting place. This initial setting establishes a tone of reflection on the afterlife and the idea that death does not necessarily bring immediate peace or understanding.

In the second stanza, the speaker describes another individual who has died for truth and is laid to rest in an adjoining room. This juxtaposition of the two deceased individuals highlights the contrast between beauty and truth. The two characters engage in a dialogue, with the second individual questioning why the speaker failed in their pursuit of beauty. The speaker responds by stating that they died for beauty. However, the individual who died for truth sees a profound connection between the two ideals, asserting that “the two are one.”

This assertion carries significant philosophical implications. It suggests that the pursuit of beauty and the pursuit of truth are not inherently separate or contradictory endeavours. Instead, they can be seen as complementary and interconnected aspects of the human experience. This idea challenges the notion that one must choose between the pursuit of aesthetic or sensory pleasures and the pursuit of intellectual or moral truths.

In the final stanza, the two deceased individuals continue their conversation “between the rooms” until moss covers their lips and “covered up our names.” This imagery symbolizes the passage of time and the gradual fading of their identities and legacies. The moss serves as a metaphor for the natural processes of decay and oblivion that eventually obscure the distinctions between individuals and their accomplishments.

“I Died for Beauty” is a contemplative poem that encourages readers to reflect on the relationship between different human ideals and the transient nature of existence. It suggests that, in the grand scheme of things, our individual pursuits of beauty or truth may converge and become indistinguishable, emphasizing the common humanity that underlies these aspirations. Emily Dickinson’s skillful use of language and symbolism makes this poem a timeless exploration of profound themes.

If you have any questions or would like to discuss the poem further, feel free to ask!